It’s One-Hit Wonder Wednesday! Each week, I’ll pick a one-hit wonder to stir nostalgia and make us all ask “what were people thinking?”

This week, it’s “Stacy’s Mom” by Fountains of Wayne.

Fountains of Wayne have had a loyal following for years but this ode to early adolescent crushes remains their only appearance on the charts, reaching #21 in 2004.

Check back next week for another One Hit Wonder Wednesday.